We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Supply Chains in the Competition Yard:All Vertical Arrangements, a Red Card?

In the thriving Indian market, competition is the driving force behind innovation, quality, and consumer choice. A pivotal aspect of this competition lies in the realm of vertical arrangements – agreements that govern relationships between entities operating at different levels of the supply chain. These arrangements, while essential for business growth, have the potential to either enhance or undermine competition. Competition Act also lays down certain categorical rules about horizontal arrangements which have been covered by our earlier article here.[2]

 Tie-in Agreement [Section 3 (4)(a)]:Any agreement requiring a purchaser of goods or services, as a condition of such purchase, to purchase some other distinct goods or services.
Exclusive Dealing Agreement [Section 3 (4)(b)]:Any agreement restricting in any manner the purchaser or the seller, as the case may be, in the course of his trade from acquiring or selling or otherwise dealing in any goods or services other than those of the seller or the purchaser or any other person.
Exclusive Distribution Agreement [Section 3 (4)(c)]:Any contract that restricts the amount of goods or services supplied or designates specific regions or markets for selling those goods or services.
Refusal to Deal [Section 3 (4)(d)]:Any agreement that, through various means, restricts or has the potential to restrict the individuals or groups to whom goods or services are sold or from whom goods or services are acquired.
Resale Price Maintenance [Section 3 (4)(e)]:This includes, in case of any agreement to sell goods or provide services, any direct or indirect restriction that the prices to be charged on the resale by the purchaser shall be the prices stipulated by the seller unless it is clearly stated that prices lower than those prices may be charged.

The right of any person to restrain any infringement under-

  1. The Copyright Act, 1957
  2. The Patents Act, 1970
  3. The Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958
  4. The Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999
  5. The Designs Act, 2000
  6. The Semi-conductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act, 2000

The right of any person to export goods from India to the extent to which the agreement or such export relates exclusively to-

  • production
  • supply
  • distribution or
  • control of goods or
  • provision of services
  • A new proviso in the Act states that nothing contained in this sub-section shall apply to an agreement entered into between an enterprise and an end consumer.

The Competition Commission of India (CCI) identified that the agreement between MMT Go and OYO violated Section 3(4)(d) in conjunction with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act. These commercial agreements were established with the intent of removing OYO’s competitors, such as FabHotels and Treebo, from the MMT Go online portal in 2018. The Commission concluded that OYO and MMT Go had an arrangement that constituted a refusal to deal, a type of vertical agreement falling under Section 3(4) (d) of the Act, which had a detrimental impact on market competition by restricting access to a vital distribution channel. In its 2019 order, CCI instructed the Director General (DG) to thoroughly investigate this matter. In 2022, after the DG’s investigation, CCI ordered MMT Go to promptly reinstate these companies to promote transparency, consumer choice, and healthy competition in the market. Further CCI imposed on MMT-Go and OYO, a monetary penalty @5% of their relevant turnover amounting to Rs. 223.48 crores and Rs. 168.88 crores respectively.

Vertical arrangements play a vital role in shaping the competitive landscape. As we’ve seen, these agreements can generally enhance efficiency and improve consumer access to goods and services. However, they also have the potential to be abused, limiting competition and consumer choice. Corporates should evaluate whether they unintentionally are creating vertical arrangements that have appreciable adverse effect on competition.