We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Time and Contract

INTRODUCTION:

If parties desire that time is material then the expression “Time is of Essence” is very important. This expression denotes that time is material while executing the contract and any delay would attract serious consequences including termination at the option of the party suffering from such delay. Further, in case of breach of this material condition of the contract, it will entitle the innocent party to consider this breach as a repudiation of the contract.

In the contracts where “time is the essence of the contract” is not the intention of the parties to the contract, then such contract does not become voidable if the contract is not performed or partly not performed at or before the stipulated time. However, the promisee is entitled to compensation from the promisor for any loss occasioned to him by such failure.

Let us examine one illustration to understand this provision in practical sense.

Scenario 1: If B accepts the supply of food after the fixed time without any objection, B cannot claim compensation for any loss occasioned by A due to the non-performance of the promise at the agreed time.

Scenario 2: If B at the time of accepting the delayed performance or accepting the late delivery of the food, gives a notice to A of his intention to claim compensation, then B has complete right to claim the compensation for any loss occasioned due to the non-performance of the promise made by A.

The above Illustration makes it clear that the intention and conduct of the Parties is very important to determine whether time is of the essence in such contract.

  • The contract for supply in a time bound manner, where the place of delivery is not mentioned.
  • Promisee agrees to grant extension of time for performance in certain conditions, or the extension is granted from time to time, without any objection.
  • The contract which does not provide for specific date for the completion but merely provides for the proper completion to happen as soon as possible or within a reasonable time.
  • If a contract provides for damages or penalties for delayed performance of contract.
  1. In the Supreme Court case of State of Kerala v. M.A. Mathai2 (decided on 9 April, 2007), it was held that in case there is any delay in the performance of reciprocal promises by an employer, the contractor gets the right to avoid the contract. However, if the employer does not avoid the contract and accepts the belated performance, he cannot claim compensation for any loss sustained by him due to delay in performance, unless he gives a notice of the same to the delaying party.
  2. In the recent Supreme Court case, Welspun Specialty Solutions Ltd. vs ONGC3 , court determined whether the contract between Welspun Specialty Solutions Ltd. (“Welspun“) and the Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (“ONGC“) was one where time is of the essence. It was discussed that, for deciding whether time is the essence of the contract, the contract shall be read as a whole and not just certain isolated provisions. The reasoning applied by the Arbitral Tribunal i.e. the concerned contract already had the provision of extension of time and imposition of liquidated damages, which are the good indicators that ‘time was not the essence of the contract’ was concurred with by the Supreme Court. On the aspect of liquidated damages, the Arbitral Tribunal held that liquidated damages, which are pre-estimated damages, cannot be granted as there was no breach of contract due to the fact that time was not the essence. Accordingly, the Arbitral Tribunal proceeded to determine the actual damages based on the evidence furnished. While upholding the Award, it was held that as the Time was not of the essence of the contract, it would not be appropriate to invoke the liquidated damages clause.

In order to bring certainty in the business, timely performance of contract is one of the essential conditions of almost all commercial contracts. However, parties should take utmost care while drafting the contract to ensure that inconsistent clauses like penalties for delay or vague clauses of performance are not incorporated in the contract. Further, parties should also act judiciously and not grant multiple extensions or accept delayed performance (without notice claiming compensation) if time is actually supposed to be of essence. Merely emphasising on the “Time as essence of the contract” is not effective and conclusive.