We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Works Contracts Unfit for MSME Benefit!

MSME sector has been gaining importance in the last few years and the legislature has also implemented various schemes to allay the issues faced by the sector. To address one of the main issues for delayed payments, the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (MSMED, Act 2006) was passed with special provisions. These provisions are covered here. [2]

However, these special provisions do not apply to Work Contract. Let’s dive deeper into the topic.

  • timelines and consequences of failure of achieving such timelines like levying liquidated damages or termination as per the arrangement of the parties;
  • payment terms;
  • responsibilities of each party;
  • representations from each side;
  • defect liability period (if agreed);
  • performance guarantees;
  • Site safety;

The works contract is a composite contract which involves both Goods and Services.

The parties under works contract intend to pay consideration not for goods involved in execution but for transfer of physical property involved in execution of the contract.

For example, work contract for construction of flat/ house consideration is not towards Cement Gitti etc., but the constructed house. Under work contract sale/ purchase of goods are not intended by parties but by necessary implication once a house or flat is built, it is transferred to buyer. Therefore, it is not a sale of goods or service or both as when a house is built, physical property is supplied and not the goods or service or both.

Works contract can be traced to be goods or service or both however it is not supply of goods or service or both as once immovable property is built under the contract, what is transferred ceased to be goods.

The determination of whether a contract is a works contract or a sale requires many factors and simply naming a document as works contract would not make the contract a works contract.

The Apex Court while deciding the issue that whether the manufacture, supply, and installation of lifts should be classified as a “sale” or a “work contract” in M/s Kone Elevator India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of Tamil Nadu and others[3] held that the question whether a particular transaction is a contract of sale, or a works contract depends upon the intention of the parties and the true construction of all the terms and conditions of the document, when there is one. A contract of sale is a contract whose main object is the transfer of the property in, and the delivery of the possession of, a chattel as a chattel to the buyer.

MSMED Act, 2006 is applicable to enterprises registered under MSMED Act, 2006 as per the classification provided as micro, small and medium under Section 7 of the MSMED Act, 2006 as amended by notification dated 1st June, 2020[5].

Under this provision the agreed payment date between the parties shall not exceed 45 days from the date of receiving goods/ services. Section 15 of MSMED Act, 2006 reads as follows:

Where any supplier supplies any goods or renders any services to any buyer, the buyer shall make payment therefor on or before the date agreed upon between him and the supplier in writing or, where there is no agreement in this behalf, before the appointed day:

Provided that in no case the period agreed upon between the supplier and the buyer in writing shall exceed forty-five days from the day of acceptance or the day of deemed acceptance.

The term “Appointed day” refers to the day immediately following the expiry of the stipulated period of (15) fifteen days from the day of acceptance[6] or the day of deemed acceptance[7] of goods or services by a buyer from a supplier.

However, the provision of delayed payment does not become applicable to MSME under work contract due to its indivisibility and composite nature. Additionally, a practical challenge arises in applying the Act to works contracts due to the ambiguity surrounding the determination of the “appointed date” or the “date of acceptance.” This determination is crucial for the Facilitation Council when resolving disputes concerning payment and the subsequent awarding of interest.

  1. In PL Adke v. Wardha Municipal Council[10], an appeal was filed before the Bombay High Court against the decision of Nasik district court rejecting the injunction petition filed under section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (“Arbitration Act”) for interim reliefs of restraining the respondent corporation from proceeding with levy of penalty, fine from deducting additional security deposit and invoking the risk and cost clause and also to restrain the respondent from blacklisting the appellant.

The respondent argued that the works contract and work order issued to the appellant for planning, designing, constructing, operating and maintaining water supply under Wardha sewerage scheme excluded arbitration as dispute resolution mechanism. Further the Respondent contended that work under works contract was not for purchase and supply but was for works contract and therefore the provisions for arbitration under MSMED Act will also not apply.

The judgment rendered by the Honorable High Court of Bombay in PL Adke v. Wardha Municipal Council has been appealed before the Apex Court in SLP (C) No. 4970 of 2021 IX and is presently awaiting consideration.

Until such clarification, every MSME must exercise caution and diligence in scrutinizing the contracts it engages in. It’s imperative to:

  1. Understand and identify the nature of the contract based on its characteristics, i.e. whether the said contract is for the sale of goods or a works contract.
  2. Negotiate contract terms and establish a mutually agreeable dispute resolution mechanism, and if the parties intend to refer to arbitration under the Arbitration Act then a clause to that effect is required to be incorporated.

Thus, comprehending contract constructs, negotiating effectively, and establishing robust dispute resolution mechanisms are vital steps in safeguarding the interests of MSMEs.