We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Importance of Consent

Consent is a key mechanism that enables individuals to exercise control over their personal data. However, not all consent is equal. The nature and quality of consent can vary depending on how it is obtained and the context in which it is given.

  • Explicit Consent: It is clearly and unambiguously stated, either verbally or in writing. For example, checking a box that says “I agree to the terms and conditions” or signing a form authorizing the use of personal data. Data Protection law across nations requires[6], such explicit consent must be obtained on the basis of clear, understandable, and sufficient information regarding the purpose, scope, and consequences of the data processing (“Informed Consent”).
  • Implied Consent: It is inferred from a person’s actions, behavior, or the circumstances. For example, when an individual includes their contact number or address in a résumé and submits it to a potential employer, it is implied that they have consented to the use of those details by the employer for the purpose of contacting them regarding employment opportunities.
  • Lack of informed consent: Consent is frequently obtained in a bundled manner, where users must accept all terms and conditions collectively, without the ability to provide selective or purpose-specific consent for different types of data processing. In practice consent are sought through privacy policies which are often lengthy, complex, and filled with legal or technical jargon, making it challenging for the average user to fully comprehend the nature and implications of what they are consenting to.
  • No Choice Mechanism in the garb of Consent: In numerous digital services, users are required to provide consent as a mandatory requirement to access essential services such as mobile apps, banking platforms, or government portals. This practice leads to forced consent, contradicting the internationally recognized principle that consent should be freely given and voluntary.
  • Lack of Accountability: Until recently, India lacked a dedicated data protection authority to oversee whether organizations obtained and used consent lawfully. Many digital platforms collect data by requiring individuals to click an “I Agree” button, often relying on bundled consent that offers no meaningful choices and shifts the entire responsibility onto the individual providing consent. As a result, accountability for the misuse of personal data after consent is given has been minimal.

The enactment of Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDP Act)[7] in August 2023, represents a major advancement in India’s data privacy framework, placing consent at the heart of personal data protection. Following are the key features of Consent under DPDP Act:

  1. Nature of Consent: The Act mandates that consent must be free, specific, informed, unconditional, and unambiguous. It should be given through clear affirmative action, ensuring that individuals are fully aware of what they are consenting to[8].
  2. Consent Manager: A significant innovation under the Act is the introduction of the Consent Manager, a registered entity with Data Protection Board that enables individuals to manage, monitor, and withdraw their consent across various platforms and service providers, promoting user control and transparency[9].
  3. Right to withdraw Consent: Individuals retain the right to withdraw their consent at any time. Upon withdrawal, data fiduciaries[10] are legally obligated to immediately stop processing the individual’s personal data, reinforcing the principle of user autonomy[11].
  4. Purpose Limitation: Consent must be obtained only for specific, clearly stated purposes. Processing data beyond these purposes is prohibited unless permitted under other lawful grounds provided by the Act, aligning with the principles of purpose limitation[12].
  5. Special provisions for children: To protect the privacy of minors, the Act requires that consent for processing the personal data of individuals under the age of 18 must be obtained from a parent or legal guardian. This adds an extra layer of protection for children in the digital ecosystem[13].
  1. Notice to be accompanied with request for consent[14]: For the purposes of complying with DPDP Act provisions related to consent it will require Data Fiduciary to provide written notice specifying:
    1. the type of personal data and the purpose for which the same is proposed to be processed;
    2. b. the manner in which she may exercise her rights under sub-section (4) of section 6 and section 13; and
    3. the manner in which the Data Principal[15] may make a complaint to the Board,
  2. Implement purpose specific consent: Instead of bundled consent, it is important that individuals are given choice to selectively agree to specific data processing activities, aligned with clearly defined purposes.
  3. Promote transparency and accountability: Organizations collecting digital data shall maintain clear records of consent, provide easy options for users to withdraw consent, and communicate changes in data practices proactively.

CONCLUSION:

While the introduction of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 is a landmark development in India’s privacy landscape, the actual practice of consent remains a work in progress. To ensure that consent goes beyond a mere formality and truly reflects user autonomy, it is essential to combine strong legal enforcement, increased public awareness, and responsible industry practices.

In May 2023, a groundbreaking GDPR fine exceeding €1.2 billion was imposed on Meta (formerly Facebook) by the Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC)[16] on U.S. tech giant Meta for unlawfully transferring personal data of EU users to the United States, marking one of the most significant milestones in the history of data protection enforcement. The DPDP Act, signals a similar regulatory approach in India. It empowers the Data Protection Board to impose monetary penalties of up to Rs.

250 crores[17] for each instance of non-compliance, including failure to take reasonable security safeguards, non-fulfilment of obligations relating to children’s data, or breach of consent requirements.

DPDP Act is likely to be notified soon and therefore it is important that organizations approach consent compliance with seriousness rather than treating it as a mere box-ticking exercise. Consent must be embedded as a substantive, user-centric safeguard at the core of data processing practices.