We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Etiquettes of Legal Communication

  • address of both the parties;
  • various modes of sending the notice like hand-delivery, by registered post A.D., by courier, by email or by WhatsApp;

A notice delivered through WhatsApp is valid and accepted in the court of law subject to proof of delivery of the said messages. This was more specifically set out by the Bombay High Court in the Judgement of SBI Cards & Payments Services Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Rohidas Jadhav & Ors2, wherein the notice sent via WhatsApp to the respondent was duly served, delivered and opened, which in the Court’s opinion is considered to be sufficient for the purpose of service of notice under Order XXI Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Therefore, the Hon’ble Justice G.S. Patel in an order dated June 11, 2018 held that, “He was served by an authorized officer of the Claimant, Ms. Fatema Kalyanwala by sending a PDF and message to his mobile number as a WhatsApp message. For the purposes of service of Notice under Order XXI Rule 22, I will accept this. I do so because the icon indicators clearly show that not only was the message and its attachment delivered to the Respondent’s number but that both were opened.”

  • A provision that each party should inform any change to the addresses so that the notices can be properly sent or received.
  • Period of notice.

Many a times we see that certain documents (agreement drafts/ notices/ letters) are marked “without Prejudice”. This phrase is often not understood. To put it simply, the implication of marking a communication as without prejudice is that the recipient of such communication cannot use such communication against the sender. The contents written in such communication are independent and the same shall not be used against the writer of the communication. The privilege of “without prejudice” applied to the written and oral communication as well.

This privilege is recognized in Section 23 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 wherein certain admissions are marked as irrelevant if it is made either upon an express condition that evidence of it is not to be given, or under circumstances from which the Court can infer that the parties agreed together that evidence of it should not be given. A communication marked as without prejudice comes under this category. This provides a protection to the Parties so that parties can freely discuss and explore a settlement in an unbiased manner.

Now the question arises is that when a Party should not use the said phrase. It is pertinent to note that writing “without prejudice” in every communication blindly will not help as that communication then cannot be used in evidence. Hence this phrase should be cautiously used wherever necessary.

“Without prejudice” should not be used where there is no settlement as it limits a party from producing such communication in the Court as evidence. The Black’s Law Dictionary defines ‘without prejudice’ as, “Where an offer or admission is made ‘without prejudice’, or a motion is denied or a bill in equity dismissed ‘without prejudice’, it is meant as a declaration that no rights or privileges of the party concerned are to be considered as thereby waived or lost, except in so far as may be expressly conceded or decided.”

MODE OF SENDING THE NOTICES:

Proper delivery of a notice or communication. Any communication needs to be properly delivered and sent to the recipient, and a receipt obtained for such communication.

MODEPRECAUTIONS
Registered Post Acknowledgement Due (RPAD)/ Speed Post A.D.Keeping the acknowledgements/ tracking report proper and shall be preserved in a file.
CourierThe acknowledgement should be obtained and in case the courier portal issues a receipt, the same should be preserved appropriately.
Hand DeliveryAcknowledgement should be obtained.
EmailThe email should be marked appropriately with delivery receipt and read receipt (if the software allows) and the same should be preserved.
WhatsAppWhatsApp notice should be sent specifically to such person and the read notification should be enabled. A screenshot of such read and received notification should be preserved.

CONCLUSION:

  1. legal communications should be properly and carefully drafted and sent.
  2. specific caution should be taken while communicating through electronic modes such as using features of high importance, confidential data, data sensitivity etc.
  3. For the purposes of tracking the delivery of communication sent through R.P.A.D. or Speed Post A.D., the facility of India Post website i.e. www.indiapost.gov.in can be availed.