We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Investment made by FOCC’s through Hybrid Instruments

Introduction:

  • More than 50% of its share capital is owned by non-residents, and
  • Control, including – the right to appoint a majority of directors, managing or influencing, company’s policies and decisions, holding significant number of shares or voting rights, having rights through shareholder or voting agreements, vests with non-residents

Under FEMA, any downstream investment made by a FOCC is treated at par with foreign investment and must comply with:

  • Sectoral caps
  • Entry routes
  • Pricing guidelines
  • Other conditions applicable to foreign direct investment
  • They offer fixed returns like debt instruments
  • Also provide the potential of ownership and capital appreciation like equity.

Optionally Convertible Debentures (OCDs) carry the potential for conversion into equity at a later date based on predetermined terms or redeem them for cash , the conversion is not mandatory and may be exercised at the option of the investor. Until it is converted OCDs carry a fixed rate of interest offering predictable returns.

On the other hand, Optionally Convertible Preference Shares (OCPS) allows holders either to covert the preference shares into shares or to redeem them. These instruments offer fixed dividends until conversion or redemption.

FDI Framework

Under the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019, only instruments that are fully and compulsorily convertible into equity are recognised as equity instruments for the purposes of FDI.

Non-Convertible instruments/ optionally convertible instruments/ partially convertible Debentures or Preference Shares shall be treated as debt and shall conform to Extra Commercial Borrowings guidelines.

Accordingly:

  • OCDs and OCPS are not treated as equity instruments
  • Investments made by an FOCC through such instruments do not qualify as FDI
  • Such investments cannot be made under the FDI framework, irrespective of future conversion possibilities

FEMA does not permit optionality in conversion where an instrument is to be classified as equity.

Meaning of ECB and Regulations Governing Hybrid Instruments

ECB refers to commercial loans raised by the eligible resident entities from recognised non-resident entities and should conform to the parameters such as:

  • Eligibility criteria for lenders and borrowers
  • Minimum average maturity requirements
  • End-use restrictions
  • All-in-cost ceilings (the maximum total cost, set by the RBI, that an Indian borrower can pay for foreign loans comprising of interest, fees)
  • Mandatory reporting to the RBI

Since OCDs and OCPS are treated as debt instruments under FEMA, investments made by an FOCC through these instruments fall within the scope of External Commercial Borrowings (ECB).

Where hybrid instruments such as OCDs or OCPS are issued with optional conversion or redemption rights are governed under ECB regulations. However, applicability of ECB regulations is contingent upon source of the funds.

Accordingly, to be considered as ECB, funds must be raised from non-resident entities recognized as eligible lenders under relevant RBI guidelines.

Investments made by a FOCC, being an Indian Resident entity do not qualify as ECB’s, therefore lies outside the scope of ECB regulations.

For investments by a Foreign Owned and Controlled Company being an Indian Resident entity, FEMA classification of the investment instrument is critical. Hybrid instruments like OCDs and OCPS, though commercially flexible, are treated as debt under the NDI Rules, 2019 but the ECB framework is not applicable.

Understanding this distinction is essential to ensure FEMA-compliant investment structures and to avoid regulatory exposure arising from misclassification of hybrid instruments.