We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

7 Myths About Contracts

The World Bank uses “enforcing contracts” as a key benchmark in assessing a country’s Ease of Doing Business[2]. It’s a recognition that robust, enforceable agreements are foundational to a secure and predictable business environment.

KNOW YOUR LAW:

CASE REFERENCE:

BELVEDERE RESOURCES DMCC versus OCL IRON AND STEEL LTD & ORS[4] :
In this case, order was placed initially on a supplier through WhatsApp and email communications (which included exchange of general terms and conditions in pdf format- with an arbitration clause).

After the supplier acted on the order, the purchaser wanted to cancel it. The supplier alleged this as wrongful termination and repudiation, as supplier suffered losses of having compelled to resell the contractual cargo to a third party at a lower market price. The supplier dragged the purchaser to arbitration in Singapore and the contract and this arbitration clause was recognized by the Delhi High Court.

Similarly, an arbitration clause contained in invoices is very much enforceable, though the letter of confirmation provided by purchaser, may or may not contain arbitration clause- Sanjiv Manmohan Gupta Versus Sai Estate Consultants Chembur Pvt. Ltd[5].

The purchaser’s challenge to arbitration clause was negated by the Bombay High Court (after two years of waiting period) and the Court said, “The invoices were accepted and partly paid for, without challenging the arbitration clause in them. Multiple opportunities to question the arbitration clause were available – each time an invoice was raised. Even if the invoices were received subject to verification, they were indeed paid for initially without any protest about the arbitration agreement.”

KNOW YOUR LAW:

Further, if you have changed any of the obligations, record it. If your business realities change — so must your contracts. Periodic reviews ensure that contracts stay relevant, reflect updated obligations, and help avoid surprises down the line.

KNOW YOUR LAW:
KNOW YOUR LAW:
KNOW YOUR LAW:
KNOW YOUR LAW:

One must remember that consideration, in legal terms, should not be equated solely with monetary compensation. Agreements entered into out of natural love affection such as gift deed, are recognized and monetary consideration is not a requisite for enforcement.

KNOW YOUR LAW:

Contract Act clearly defines that objects of a contract matter and any contract made for objectives which are illegal or against the public policy will be void. Off late, due to delay in judicial enforcements, many parties include clauses to state that any proceedings filed beyond a fixed period are not to be entertained or that parties will not litigate on this matter. These might restrain legal rights of a party and however logical it may seem is not enforceable. Further, the period within which the legal action can be filed is determined by the limitation statute and cannot be altered by the parties, extension or reduction, both are not possible.

In fact, The Indian Contract Act 1872 clearly states that below set of agreement would be considered void:

  • Agreements that are without Consideration
  • Agreements which are in Restraint of Marriage
  • Agreements which are in Restraint of Trade, with some exceptions (like sale of goodwill).
  • Agreements which defeat the provisions of any law;
  • Wagering Agreements: Section 30: Agreements based on wagering (bets) are void. (Note: They are void, not illegal, unless local laws make them so.