We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Disclaimer Provision: A Tool of Caution

Good to see and hold, but if broken considered sold.

Picture does not represent the product inside the pack.

Investments may be subject to market risk.

Cigarette smoking is injurious to health.

This movie has no connection with real-life, or with any person living or dead and any connection is a coincidence.

What are the first thoughts which come to our mind when we look at these statements? These statements may appear cautionary in nature which warn the readers about certain consequences. Making users aware of the essential nature of certain things is the main objective of disclaimers [1].

Considering that some people will always engage in risky behaviour and that the government/ regulatory authority has little control over how people conduct themselves, Government/ regulatory authority often aim to mitigate the harm by regulating the use through some restrictions/ policies and guidelines. For example, instead of banning motorcycles entirely, governments mandate usage of helmets to reduce injury severity in accidents. Similarly, product and service providers in high-risk sectors are required to provide clear disclaimers. These government/ regulatory authorities measures aim to inform consumers about potential dangers, empowering them to make informed choices.

Are these statements always enforceable? Why are these statements made, when some of them may actually be harmful to the person selling the products? Is it mandatory to put such disclaimers? Lets find out and understand with some specific examples:

Under these rules, the publishers of online content have also been brought under many restrictions while displaying any scenes of consumption of tobacco products, like displaying health spots, anti tobacco health warnings etc. It is also prescribed that the anti-tobacco health warning message, health spot and audio-visual disclaimer, shall be in the same language as used in the online curated content. The warning needs to be a prominent static message at the bottom of the screen during the period of display of the tobacco products or their use in the programme along with a disclaimer requiring display of an audio-visual disclaimer on the ill-effects of tobacco use, of minimum twenty seconds duration each, in the beginning and middle of the programme. The disclaimers for tobacco products also generally provide a clarification that the actor does not promote usage of tobacco.

Further, such disclaimers are also mandatory in advertisements through audio-visual media like television. The disclaimer is required to be displayed on the screen and the parameters of display like amount of time, font, screen space etc. are also emphasized[4].

Most movies begin with various kinds of disclaimers, which may have been inserted either by the producers or sometimes are directed by authorities. A common disclaimer one sees is when the production house disclaims any kind of relationship or connect that the movie has with any living or dead person. Sometimes, the content of the movie may be such that a particular community finds it offensive and thus approaches the Court for a stay on such movie.

An important case in this regard pertains to release of the movie Nyay- which was supposedly linked to the story of the late actor Sushant Singh Rajput (SSR).

The film makers had not obtained the consent of the family and stated that the movie intended to portray the struggle of upcoming actors and did not touch any personal or private life of the actor. While the Court examined various issues related to celebrity rights, privacy rights and specifically posthumous exercise of personality rights, one of the factors also pertained to a disclaimer. Disclaimer included in the movie was:

Disclaimer: all characters, names, locations, buildings, properties, assigned are all fictitious, if there is any resemblance to any location, person, property, etc. it is purely coincidental and not intentional. Any mention of a community, language or region in this film is not intended to inflict contempt at any point. The film must therefore be viewed as purely a non-commenting source of harmless entertainment not designed to hurt or disdain any individual or a community.

The Court specifically observed that the film is neither portrayed as a biopic, nor a factual narration of what transpired in the life of the SSR, and are depicted to be complete fictional and inspired from certain events which have occurred in the past and have been widely discussed and are available in public domain and permitted release, while keeping the scope open for enquiry on the truthfulness of the disclaimer.

  • a disclaimer in not less than 3mm size shall be given at appropriate place on the label stating that – “This is only a brand name or trade mark and does not represent its true nature”.
  • All disclaimers related to a claim shall be conspicuous and legible.
  • The additional conditions or disclaimer statements may be used with non-addition claims to assist consumer understanding of the claims provided that the disclaimer statements shall be conspicuous and legible.

When this visitor came out of the hotel at about 1 a.m., he was informed that his vehicle had been driven away by another person. Upon enquiry with the security officer, he found that three young boys had come to the hotel in their separate car, parked it, and gone inside the hotel. Later, they came out and asked the valet to bring their car to the porch. During this process, one of the boys, picked up the keys of the car of the owner from the desk, went to the car parking and stole the Maruti Zen car. Though the security guard tried to stop him, he sped away. A complaint was lodged with the police, but the car remained untraced.

After multiple rounds of litigation for 20 years, before the District Consumer Commission, State Consumer Commission and National Consumer Commission, the matter reached the Apex Court and the Apex Court applied various principles of law and after referring to a plethora of judgement specifically applied the rule of negligence on the hotel and stated that,

The case was decided in favor of the vehicle owner and compensation was awarded to the owner, disregarding the printed disclaimer or notice on parking tag.

Disclaimers may work as a powerful legal shied in certain cases. To ensure that the common public is not deceived by attractive appearances of certain products, government makes it mandatory to include disclaimers on certain products so that an informed choice is made by the consumer. However, one must remember that Courts may well disregard the entire disclaimer if it is found that that the maker of such disclaimer has breached any of its fundamental duties.