We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Horizontal Agreements under Competition Act

Thus, horizontal agreements are the arrangements between rival distributors, manufacturer, retailers who operate at the same level of supply chain.

Price FixingOutput ControlMarket SharingBid Rigging3
When competitors directly or indirectly fix the cost of the goods or services.When competitors mutually create an artificial scarcity by collectively controlling production or manufacturing or supply of the products.When competitors identify and/or share their specific market location to the exclusion of others and their production of or provisions of supply or delivery of services by splitting the market area.When competitors collude, with each other and file similar bids.
TECHNIQUES
Raise or cut the cost or retain the same price /discounts or identical accounting techniques etc.When there is scarcity there is a high demand for any product and thus the price of that product ultimately rises.Geographical division of markets by the competitors amongst themselves. 
APPPRECIABLE ADVERSE EFFECT ON COMPETITION
Competitors are already familiar with each other’s price techniques.Consumers are deprived of the goods or services and may be required to pay higher.Consumers have limited choice and are deprived from purchasing from other retailers. This also gives an unfair advantage of overcharging in their particular allocated areas.It weakens the bidding process and can lead to a manipulated price that is higher than what might have been resulted in a free market.

“It has been found that Ola and Uber do not facilitate cartelization and Anti-competitive practices, between drivers, who are independent individuals, who act independently of each other”.

Exemption Granted Under Section 3 (3):

It is to be noted that Section 3(3) is not applicable to a joint venture, if it increases the efficiency of production, supply, distribution, storage, acquisition or provisions of services. Joint Venture signifies a beneficial arrangement that seeks to increase the efficiency of the parties to the arrangement. Such exclusion is practically justifiable as well as it is essential for companies or enterprises to enter into such agreement which strengthen their efficiency and benefit them.