We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Justice Beyond Signatures: Arbitration Agreement Features

Let us understand this better with an illustration.

A entered into a Services Agreement with B, wherein B was supposed to provide certain services related to administrative services through its employees to be deputed at the office site of A. B and BB are affiliates and operate on the same premises and many employees though being on pay roll of BB also work for B.

During the course of deputation, A notices that its confidential information is getting leaked and that leakage is attributable to deployed personnel and wishes to sue them to obtain an urgent injunction against such leakage. However, the employees are not employees of B but BB.

The agreement between A and B provides for arbitration as dispute resolution and any injunction would be fruitful only against the relevant party. BB refuses to be a party to the arbitration proceedings as no agreement is executed between A and BB.

Can the arbitral tribunal or the court grant an injunction of this nature against BB and its employees?

One guiding light, with respect to inclusion of non-signatories in an arbitration, is the group doctrine principle that was promulgated by the Supreme Court in the judgement of Chloro Control India (P) Ltd. v. Severn Trent Water Purification Inc. (Chloro controls)[2]. In this case, the Supreme Court acknowledged that cases of composite transactions involving multi-party agreement give rise to peculiar challenges where non-signatories may be implicated in the dispute because of their legal relationship and involvement in the performance of contractual obligations. To remedy such situations, it was held that the group of companies’ doctrine could be applied to systematically evaluate the facts and circumstances to determine “a clear intention of the parties to bind both, the signatory as well as the non-signatory parties” to the arbitration agreement.

This judgement dealt with a situation where the success of the joint venture agreement was dependent upon the fulfilment of all the ancillary agreements. In this context, this Court observed that all the ancillary agreements were relatable to the parent agreement and the ancillary agreements were intrinsically linked with each other, to the extent that they could not be severed. This in the view of the court indicated the intention of the parties to refer all disputes arising out of the parent agreement and ancillary agreements to the arbitral tribunal.

Recently, Chloro Controls was referred to the constitution bench of the Supreme Court questioning the group doctrine, in Cox and Kings Ltd. Vs. SAP India Pvt. Ltd. and Ors. [3]

‘Group of Companies’ doctrine in the jurisprudence of Indian arbitration provides that an arbitration agreement which is entered into by a company within a group of companies may bind non-signatory affiliates, if the circumstances are such as to demonstrate the mutual intention of the parties to bind both signatories and non-signatories. This doctrine is called into question purportedly on the ground that it interferes with the established legal principles such as party autonomy, privity of contract, and separate legal personality.

The Supreme Court again discussed this doctrine in terms of the reference questions and particularly on the definition of the term “Parties”. It was held that the definition of “parties” includes both the signatory as well as non-signatory parties. Conduct of the non-signatory parties could be an indicator of their consent to be bound by the arbitration agreement.

14TH December 2010: Cox and Kings Ltd (“C&K”) entered into SAP Software End User License Agreement and Software Agreement under which the C&K were made licensee of ERP software which was developed and owned by SAP India Private Limited i.e. SAP INDIA. SAP GMBH was the holding company and was also in regular correspondence with C&K.

2015: While C&K was developing its own e-commerce platform, SAP recommended a Hybris Solution to C&K as it would be 90% compatible with the C&K’s own software. Respondents also claimed that this would be to C&K’s benefit as it would take only take 10 months to complete the remaining 10% customization. To execute the Hybris Solution, the aforesaid agreed arrangement was divided into 3 transactions i.e. Software License Agreement, Services General Terms and Conditions Agreement which had an Arbitration Clause as well and another agreement for customization of the software was entered into for the customization of the software.

2016: Due to several issues in the implementation of the Hybris Solution, the contractual framework in this regard was rescinded by C&K. Following which, all the necessary resources were withdrawn by SAP.

Aggrieved by this withdrawal, C&K demanded a refund of Rs. 45 crores.

29th October 2017: As the disputes could not get resolved even after several meetings, SAP INDIA invoked Arbitration Clause and demanded payment of Rs.17 crores on the ground of wrongful termination of the contract by the C&K. Arbitral Tribunal was constituted, and it is important to note that the SAP GMBH was not made a party of these arbitration proceedings. Alongside, C&K filed an Application under Section 16 of the Act contenting that all the four agreements were a composite transaction.

Thereafter, National Company Law Tribunal appointed an Interim Resolution Professional to an application under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 made against C&K. NCLT directed the parties to adjourn the Arbitration Proceedings as Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process was initiated.

7th November 2019: Thereafter, a second notice to invoking Arbitration was sent by the C&K arraying SAP GMBH this time, but no response was received from the Respondents’ side.

Aggrieved, C&K filed an application before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India under Section 11(6) of the Act praying constitution of an Arbitral Tribunal.

This case referred the matter to the larger bench and ultimately, last month in 2023, the Supreme Court held that the requirement of a written arbitration agreement under Section 7 does not exclude the possibility of binding non-signatory parties. Under the Act, the concept of a “party” is distinct and different from the concept of “persons claiming through or under” a party to the arbitration agreement. The Court also held that “The group of companies’ doctrine should be retained in the Indian arbitration jurisprudence considering its utility in determining the intention of the parties in the context of complex transactions involving multiple parties and multiple agreements. At the referral stage, the referral court should leave it for the arbitral tribunal to decide whether the non-signatory is bound by the arbitration agreement”.

  1. The mutual intent of the parties;
  2. The relationship of a non-signatory to a party which is a signatory to the agreement;
  3. The commonality of the subject-matter;
  4. The composite nature of the transactions; and
  5. The performance of the contract