We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Mediation:- Crafting Peaceful Solution for Conflicts

WHAT IS MEDIATION?

  • Blacks Law dictionary defines mediation as “Intervention; interposition; the act of a third person who interferes between two contending parties with a view to reconcile them or persuade them to adjust or settle their dispute. In international law and diplomacy, the word denotes the friendly interference of a state in the controversies of others, for the purpose, by its influence and by adjusting their difficulties, of keeping the peace in the family of nations[2].”
  • Section 2(25) Consumer Protection Act 2019[3] “mediation” means the process by which a mediator mediates the consumer disputes.
  • Section 4 Mediation Act, 2023 (“Act”)[4] :- Mediation shall be a process, whether referred to by the expression mediation, pre-litigation mediation, online mediation, community mediation, conciliation or an expression of similar import, whereby party or parties, request a third person referred to as mediator or mediation service provider to assist them in their attempt to reach an amicable settlement of a dispute.
  • Commercial Courts (Pre-Institution Mediation and Settlement) Rules, 2018[5], Rule2(e) “mediation” means a process undertaken by a Mediator to resolve, reconcile and settle a commercial dispute between the parties thereto.
  • Voluntary Mediation- The Parties may decide to adopt mediation as dispute resolution mechanism, and add the appropriate clause in the agreement.
  • Reference of Courts- The Court can refer the case to mediation under section 89 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’) or under special legislations such as Section 37 of Consumer Protection Act, 2019, after case is filed with Court, or under the CPC Order 32A Rule 3 in matters related to family disputes.
  • Mandatory Prelitigation Mediation– Under the Commercial Courts Act Section 12A.

ADVANTAGES OF MEDIATION

  • Participative, Voluntary- Parties directly participate and present their own case and Parties may opt out of mediation in case they feel so..
  • Speedy, Efficient, Economical- Time and Money saving for both Parties involved.
  • Fair Process- A neutral third party will access the case and bring parties to common platform.
  • Simple, Informal- This type of environment in mediation helps to schedule it flexibly, thereby helping the parties, and effective communication is sought between the Parties.
  • Settlement of entire conflict of parties vs a specific dispute between the parties.
  • Mutually Benefical settlement- Mediation aims for win-win situation for both the Parties, so neither party is aggrieved by the order.
Introduced in Rajya Sabha20th December 2021
Referred to Standing Committee20th December 2021
Report submitted by Standing Committee13th July 2022
Passed by Rajya Sabha1st August 2023
Passed by Lok Sabha7th August 2023
Passed by Lok Sabha [7]15th September 2023

MEDIATION ACT 2023-SALIENT FEATURES

The mediator so appointed, is required to provide a declaration disclosing any existing or potential personal, professional, financial, or other scenario that could create a conflict of interest or that could lead to legitimate concerns about his objectivity or independence as a mediator in the particular mediation matter. In the absence of a mutually agreed-upon mediator, the parties have the option to submit a request to the institutions that provide the mediation services (“Mediation Service Provider”) [11] for the appointment of a mediator from their established panel of mediators. This selection process will factor in the parties’ preferences and the mediator’s appropriateness for effectively resolving the dispute.

The Mediator can be terminated by either Party, or if there is conflict of interest, or his voluntary withdrawal from mediation due to any reason. In case of termination of mediator, (in case other than institutional mediation), then another mediator may be appointed within 7 (seven) days from such termination of mediator. In case of Mediation Service Provider, the Mediation Service Provider shall appoint the new mediator within 7 (seven) days from such termination.

  • disputes against minors or persons with disabilities,
  • criminal offenses which require prosecution,
  • taxation matters and collection of taxation or refunds,
  • any telecom related disputes, or
  • disputes where the rights of multiple parties are affected, public matters.

6. What is a mediation settlement agreement?[13]

Mediation settlement agreement shall mean a document which will be in a nature of agreement of some or all of the parties of mediation have agreed upon regarding the points in the disputes raised in mediation. Such mediation settlement agreement should be authenticated by the mediator of the dispute. In such an agreement, parties may insert terms which are extending beyond the scope of the mediation.

The mediation settlement agreement should be in writing and signed by both the parties. In case of any institutional mediator, the mediation settlement agreement should be submitted to the institution and mediator, who will then attach a covering letter to the same, and submit the report to both the parties. In other cases, the mediator shall authenticate such mediation settlement agreement and submit copies of the agreement to both the parties.

In case, where the mediation is not successful, then the mediator shall prepare a failure report and submit a signed copy to the disputing parties. It’s crucial to remember that the non – settlement report will be handled with confidentiality in order to protect the interest of the parties. This means that the mediator is not allowed to disclose the causes of lack of settlement or any details regarding the conduct of the parties throughout the mediation process.

7. Can a mediation settlement agreement be challenged?[14]

Yes. While a mediation settlement agreement is binding on the parties, it can be challenged on limited grounds . In case a mediation settlement agreement is sought to be challenged by either party, the parties may file an application in the Court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction within 90 days of the date of receipt of the copy of the mediation settlement agreement. A mediation settlement agreement may be challenged only on the four grounds namely

  1. Fraud
  2. Corruption
  3. Impersonation
  4. Where the mediation was conducted in disputes or matters which are not fit for mediation.

8. Does the Act provide for Online Mediation?[15]

Yes. In this era of digital world, the Act also provides for online mediation for the parties involved. The online mode for the mediation may include audio or video conferencing, encrypted communication, email as may be preferred by the parties. The procedure of online mediation shall be as per the specification by the Act. The other requirements of mediation such as integrity, confidentiality shall remain the same.

9. Is there a body to govern the mediation in India?[16]

Yes. The Act provides for formation of an independent body known as Mediation Council of India (“Council”) to discharge the functions stated under this Act. The Act also specifies the location of head offices and other offices. It also specifies the composition of the council, salaries of the council members, appointment of committees, duties and functions of the council.

10. What is community mediation?[17]

Under the Act, section 44, recognises the concept of community mediation. Community mediation is not a new concept in India. Since long times, panchayats have been mediating the disputes between households in villages or in communities. The crux of community mediation is the same. The disputing parties have to make an application before the concerned Authority constituted under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 or District Magistrate or Sub-Divisional Magistrate in areas where no such Authority has been constituted, for referring the dispute to mediation. There shall be a panel of three mediators to facilitate the settlement of disputes. The procedure of community mediation is also stated in detail in the Act.

11. Is there a provision for mediation institutes?[18]

The Act also provides for concepts of institutional mediation. Such mediation service providers shall also be graded in the manner specified. The mediation service providers shall perform functions such as maintaining panel of mediators, providing services of mediator, provide all the infrastructure facility, secretarial assistance, promote ethical and professional conduct between mediators etc.

Conclusion:

The mediation scenario in India as an alternative form of dispute resolution is still in its nascent stage. The passing of the Act is a significant step towards alternative dispute resolution and it shall facilitate a range of cases domestic as well as international. This Act will bring common man closer to availing justice at a reasonable cost and limited timeframe. It shall remain to be seen whether the Mediation Act, shall be implemented in letter and spirit and it shall fulfil the intentions of the legal connoisseurs. The enactment of the Mediation Act is constructive and motivating step towards reforming the field of conflict resolution. Without the necessity for formal adjudication, it offers parties a valuable opportunity to resolve all conflicts willingly and effectively.