We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

When Friendship Turns into Liability

A private company appointed a new director a respected businessman and close friend of one of the existing directors. His reputation brought instant credibility to the company, that helped the company to obtain large loans from banks.

To support the borrowing, the newly appointed director signed as a personal guarantor and was made an authorized signatory to bank accounts. Trusting his friend and confidence in the company’s prospects, he neither questioned the financials nor reviewed repayment arrangements. The newly appointed director did not subscribe to any shares.

Within few years, the company defaulted. The original directors vanished, leaving the new director solely answerable. The bank invoked the personal guarantee, and he was compelled to liquidate personal assets to satisfy the loan. In order to safeguard his reputation and standard in the market he repaid everything. The original directors left him in a blackhole, while they refused to take or respond to his calls.

This situation is common in small, privately held companies where decisions are informal and relationships replace rigorous oversight.

Months later, a major financial fraud surfaced, and the executive directors were arrested for siphoning funds. The non-executive director, however, was spared. As he had never signed bank documents, had no role in daily affairs, and never attended board meetings related to the fraudulent transactions.

Ordinarily, directors are not personally liable for company debts unless they:

  1. Commit fraud or misfeasance;
  2. Act beyond their authority; or
  3. Provide a personal guarantee or specific undertaking.

When Personal Guarantees Pierce the Corporate Veil:

Sections 126–128 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 govern contracts of guarantee. Section 128 clearly states that a surety’s liability is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor unless the contract provides otherwise.

Once a director executes a guarantee, lenders may proceed directly against them without first exhausting remedies against the company.

In Bank of Bihar Ltd. v. Damodar Prasad (AIR 1969 SC 297) and Industrial Investment Bank of India Ltd. v. Biswanath Jhunjhunwala (2009) 9 SCC 478, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that guarantors cannot evade responsibility merely because the borrower defaults or absconds.

Therefore, in Case 1, the director’s personal liability was absolute once he signed the guarantee, regardless of his operational role.

Non-Executive Directors: Limited Role, Limited Liability

Section 149(12) of the Companies Act provides that an independent director or non-executive director not being promoter or key managerial personnel, shall be held liable, only in respect of such omission or commission by a company which had occurred with his knowledge, attributable through Board process and with his consent, connivance or where he had not acted diligently.

Ministry of Corporate Affairs has also issued circulars from time to time to emphasize that non-executive directors should not be prosecuted unless there’s adequate proof that they had knowledge through Board process or that the acts of omission or commission were committed by the company with their consent, connivance or negligence.

There is no bar on commencement of prosecution or any other legal proceedings against such directors, they can however, be exonerated by the concerned authorities / courts if their bona-fides are proved.

Key Judicial References:

  • Sunita Palita & Ors. v. Panchami Stone Quarry (2022) 10 SCC 152 – Independent and non-executive directors cannot be held vicariously liable unless there is clear evidence of their involvement in the act constituting the offence.
  • Pooja Ravinder Devidasani v. State of Maharashtra (2014) 16 SCC 1 – Mere designation as director at the time of default does not establish criminal liability.

In Case 2, these principles shielded the non-executive director because he could demonstrate complete non-involvement and absence of knowledge.

Safeguards for Directors:

Whether executive or non-executive, every director should adopt certain protective practices.

  1. Conduct Thorough Due Diligence before one is onboarded as a Director
    • Review the company’s financials, statutory filings, and existing loan obligations.
    • Use the MCA portal to verify pending charges or defaults.
    • Seek independent advice before accepting directorship in a closely held entity.
  2. Exercise Caution with Personal Guarantees
    • Understand the scope, duration, and limit of any guarantee.
    • Avoid blanket or continuing guarantees without defined ceilings.
    • Obtain written indemnity from the company, recorded in board minutes.
  3. Define and Document Your Role
    • For non-executive directors, clarify that the appointment is advisory or honorary.
    • Ensure the letter of appointment sets out the limited scope of involvement.
    • Record dissent or abstention in board minutes when you disagree with risky proposals.
  4. Maintain Compliance Records
    • Retain copies of resolutions, financial reports, and correspondences that evidence your oversight.
    • Attend meetings where key financial decisions are made or document reasons for absence.
  5. Obtain Directors’ & Officers’ (D&O) Liability Insurance
    • A robust D&O policy can cover defense costs and damages arising from management decisions or allegations of negligence.
  6. Don’t provide your own property documents as collateral.
    • Do not hand over your original papers.
    • Do not execute any Special Power of attorney in connection to property and handover to Banks and Financial Institutions.
    • Do not execute any papers connected to top-up of loan or shifting of loan from one bank to another; and
    • Don’t be a signatory to a Bank that you do not want to operate in individual capacity.

Key Takeaways:

  1. Directors must independently verify company affairs before lending their name or signature.
  2. Personal guarantees override limited liability. Once executed, they expose private assets to corporate risk.
  3. Non-executive directors enjoy statutory protection—but only when their non-involvement and diligence can be proven.
  4. Closely held companies require higher vigilance, as informal governance increases the potential for personal exposure.
  5. Documentation, diligence, and insurance are the best shields against unforeseen liability.