We are a law firm, based in Mumbai.

Phone: 9004523497 | Email: info@ynzgroup.co.in

Developers Better Hurry, Delayed Possession Not Only A Buyer’s Worry!

Thus, RERA puts a cogent responsibility on the promoter to deliver the possession of the premises within the committed timeframe and failure to do so attracts clear consequences.

Shree Shakun Realty Pvt. Ltd. vs. Vijay Solanki[4]: In this complaint agreement for sale was executed and registered on 10 January 2014. Promoter agreed to give possession of the flat on or before 31 December 2014. However, Promoter failed to hand over possession of flat on or before December 2014. Allottee demanded refund of amount paid to Promoter along with interest and compensation by withdrawing from the project under Section 18(1) of RERA. The Regulatory Authority heard both the sides and directed Promoter to refund the amount paid by Allottee along with interest. Aggrieved Promoter has filed appeal and relied on clause 8 of the agreement for sale to claim reasonable extension for giving possession due to unavoidable circumstances. In view of Appellant Authority, in Section 8 of MOFA extension for handing over possession is initially for 3 months and thereafter for 3 months for reasons beyond control. However, there is no such extension provided under Section 18 (1) of RERA.

Thus, due date as mentioned in the agreement for sale is absolute and it is not subject to any extension under Section 18 (1) of RERA. The Appellate Tribunal dismissed the appeal filed by Promoter and confirmed the impugned order dated 30th January 2019 passed in the Complaint No. CC006000000056702. The order of the Appellate Authority was challenged in the High Court. The High Court also dismissed the appeal and upheld the impugned order passed by MahaRERA and Appellant Tribunal and directed that the amount which the allottee has paid to the Promoter be retuned back with simple interest at the rate of 10.55% p.a. from the date of their payment till the refund.

Jervis and Rose Creado vs Aishwarya Light Construction Company[5]: In this complaint, MahaRERA in its order had denied the Allottee to claim interest on delayed possession of flat as the agreement of sale was not registered. Since the Promoter accepted 20% of consideration value of the flat from the Allottee.

Authority has directed the said Promoter to register the agreement of sale within 30 days under Section 18 of RERA. The order of regulatory authority was challenged in the Appellant Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal passed the order on 17 June 2022 setting aside MahaRERA’s impugned order and directed the Promoter to pay the interest at the rate of State Bank of India highest Marginal Cost Lending Rate plus 2% on the amount paid by the allottee from January 2018 till the actual possession of flat to be handed over. In addition, tribunal ordered the Promoter to pay Rs 10,000 as cost to the Allottee.

It was held that in the absence of a formal agreement, any other document, such as an allotment letter, brochure, pamphlet or email communication mentioning the date of possession can be considered to work out the delay in possession.

Impact of Force Majeure Event:

Section 6 of RERA has envisaged force Majeure event and states that the registration granted under RERA may be extended by the Regulatory Authority on an application made by the promoter due to force majeure occurrence. For the purpose of this section, the expression of “Force Majeure” shall mean war, flood, drought, fire, cyclone, earthquake or any other calamity caused by nature affecting the regular development of the real estate project. It seems that there is no such provision in RERA extending the timelines committed for handover of the possession to the buyer. Generally, most of the agreement for sale contains force majeure clause which exempt promoter’s liability on occurrence of force majeure event. The promoter takes disadvantage of such clause as per their convenience.

In one such instance, demonetization was cited as a force majeure event by Tanish Associates Partnership Firm[5] but the contention was not accepted. In this appeal the promoters were aggrieved by the order of the MAhaRERA to pay interest  for  the  delayed  possession  from 01 July 2017 till 11 December 2019 together with cost of Rs. 20,000/- and thus promoters had filed appeal before the Appellate Tribunal. The learned counsel for promoters submitted that project was delayed because of the demonetization scheme. In view of Tribunal, delay on account of demonetization will not come to rescue of promoter from legal liabilities under RERA. Hence the appeal was dismissed. An exception was made during the pandemic and Covid-19 pandemic was considered as a natural calamity and a force majeure event by Finance Minister of India[6].

In order to control the situation of Covid-19 the MahaRERA by its order dated 02 April 2020 extended registration and completion dates for 6 months for all real estate projects expiring on or after 15 March 2020[7]. Similar relief was announced in certain other states as well.

Appeal Under RERA:

Any person aggrieved by any decision or order of the real estate regulatory authority or adjudicating officer may file an appeal before the real estate appellate tribunal having jurisdiction over the matter. Furthermore, any person aggrieved by any decision or order of the real estate appellate tribunal may file an appeal before the High Court of the state having jurisdiction over the matter. Every appeal has to be filed within a period of sixty days from the date on which a copy of the decision or order is received by the aggrieved person.

Jurisdiction Barred:

Under section 79 of RERA, civil courts are barred to entertain disputes in respect of matters which real estate regulatory authority or adjudicating officer or real estate appellate tribunal is empowered under RERA to determine. However, the consumer forums (National, State or District) are not barred. Section 71 of RERA allows the buyer to withdraw his complaint from the consumer forum (National, State or District) regarding matter under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19 of RERA and file an application before the adjudicating officer under RERA. The Adjudicating officer has to dispose off such application within a period of sixty days from the date of receipt of such application.

Penalties:

There are different penalties mentioned under RERA depending upon the offences for non-compliance of provisions and orders of regulatory authority and appellate tribunal.

OffencePenalty
Violation of other provisions of RERA by promoter other than provided under section 3 or section 4 of RERAPenalty extends up to 5% of the estimated cost of real estate project
Failure to comply with orders of Authority by promoterPenalty for every day of defaults which may cumulatively extend up to 5% of the estimated cost of real estate project
Failure to comply with orders of Appellate Tribunal by promoterImprisonment up to 3 years or fine for every day which may cumulatively extend up to 10% of estimated cost of real estate project or with both penalties
Failure to comply with orders of Authority by real estate agentPenalty for every day of default which may cumulatively extend up to 5% of the estimated cost of the property whose sale or purchase has been facilitated by the real estate agent
Failure to comply with orders of Appellate Tribunal by real estate agentImprisonment up to 1 year or fine for every day which may cumulatively extend up to 10% of estimated cost of the property whose sale or purchase has been facilitated by the real estate agent or with both penalties

Conclusion:

We can draw a conclusion that the RERA regulates the promoter and gives protection to the buyer’s investment. If every buyer is looking at home as a dream, the RERA helps to achieve this dream and in case someone breaches, the regulations can suitably penalise the Promoter. All the buyers should be aware about the provisions of RERA. The major benefit of this act is transparency in transaction and speedy redressal of any dispute between promoter and buyer.